EU Parliament Blocks Mass-Scanning of Our Chats—What's Next?

2 hours 49 minutes ago

The EU’s so-called Chat Control plan, which would mandate mass scanning and other encryption breaking measures, has had some good news lately. The most controversial idea, the forced requirement to scan encrypted messages, was given up by EU member states. And now, another win for privacy: the EU Parliament has dealt a real blow to voluntary mass-scanning of chats by voting to not prolong an interim derogation from e-Privacy rules in the EU. These rules allowed service providers, temporarily, to scan private communication.  

But no one should celebrate just yet. We said there is more to it, and voluntary scanning is a key part. Unlike in the U.S., where there is no comprehensive federal privacy law, the general and indiscriminate scanning of people’s messages is not legal in the EU without a specific legal basis. The e-Privacy derogation law, which gave (limited) cover for such activities, has now expired. Does that mean mass scanning will stop overnight?  

Not really. 

Companies have continued similar scanning practices during past gaps. Google, Meta, Microsoft, and Snap have already signaled in a joint statement to “continue to take voluntary action on our relevant Interpersonal Communication Services.” Whether this indicates continued scanning of our private communication is not entirely clear, but what is clear is that such activity would now risk breaching EU law. Then again, lack of compliance with EU data protection and privacy rules is nothing new for big tech in Europe. 

Most importantly, the “Chat Control” proposal for mandatory detection of child abuse material (CSAM) is still alive and being negotiated. It has shifted the focus toward so-called risk mitigation measures, such as problematic age verification and voluntary activities. If platforms are expected to adopt these as part of their compliance, they risk no longer being truly voluntary. While mass scanning may be gone on paper, some broader concerns remain.  

So, where does this leave us? The immediate priority is to make sure the expired exception for mass scanning is not revived. At the same time, lawmakers need to pull the teeth from the currently negotiated Chat Control proposal by narrowing risk mitigation measures. This means ensuring that age verification does not become a default requirement and “voluntary activities” are not turned into an expectation to scan our communications.   

As we said before, this is a zombie proposal. It keeps coming back and must not be allowed to return through the back door. 

Christoph Schmon

【出版トピック】作家・綾辻行人さんの作品装う“偽本”がAmazonに出現 本人が注意喚起!

6 hours 13 minutes ago
 作家の綾辻行人さんは、4月3日、自身の作品を装った偽の電子書籍がAmazonで販売されているとして、広く注意するよう呼びかけた。 偽の電子書籍のタイトルは『続・十角館の殺人』『十角館の再訪』。綾辻さんは、「私はまったく関知しておらず、驚きました。誰かが生成AIで勝手に作ったもののようです」と説明している。 綾辻さんが作家デビューを果たした著書『十角館の殺人』(講談社ノベルス)を想起させるもので、書影には、同書の表紙を手掛けた漫画家・喜国雅彦さんのイラストを模した画像を使って..
JCJ

「反差別条例が泣いている」三重県が外国籍職員採用廃止を検討 田中宏一橋大学名誉教授に聞く

14 hours 27 minutes ago
高市政権下で先鋭化する排外主義が、全国初の包括的反差別条例を制定した三重県で噴出している。職員採用で緩和したはずの国籍条項を復活し、外国籍者の採用廃止を検討すると知事が言い出したのだ。問題に詳しいジャーナリスト、中村一成 […]
admin

「真実の側に立てた」 崔善愛

15 hours 45 minutes ago
 2011年3月11日、福島県内に住んでいた瞳さん(仮名)は小学6年だった。学校から帰るとランドセルを玄関に放り投げ、公園で友だちとブランコに乗っていたとき、大地震が起きた。それでも春休みに入り、毎日のように友だちと遊ん […]
admin

[B] 遺骨返還問題で政府と交渉 制度の壁と期限迫る中での課題

21 hours 51 minutes ago
朝鮮半島出身の強制動員被害者の遺骨返還をめぐり、市民団体や遺族関係者は3月24日、日本政府と交渉を行った。長年停滞してきた問題の構造的課題が改めて浮き彫りとなるとともに、寺院での保管期限が迫る中で解決の緊急性も強く意識されている。(小栗俊也)
日刊ベリタ