Aggregator

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit correctly held that Grindr, a popular dating app, can’t be held responsible for matching users and enabling them to exchange messages that led to real-world harm. EFF and the Woodhull Freedom Foundation filed an amicus brief in the Ninth Circuit in support of Grindr.

Grindr and other dating apps are possible thanks to strong Section 230 immunity. Without this protection, dating apps—and other platforms that host user-generated content—would have more incentive to censor people online. While real-world harms do happen when people connect online, these can be directly redressed by holding perpetrators who did the harm accountable.

The case, Doe v. Grindr, was brought by a plaintiff who was 15 years old when he signed up for Grindr but claimed to be over 18 years old to use the app. He was matched with other users and exchanged messages with them. This led to four in-person meetings that resulted in three out of four adult men being prosecuted and sentenced for rape.

The plaintiff brought various state law claims against Grindr centering around the idea that the app was defectively designed, enabling him to be matched with and to communicate with the adults. The plaintiff also brought a federal civil sex trafficking claim.

Grindr invoked Section 230, the federal statute that has ensured a free and open internet for nearly 30 years. Section 230(c)(1) specifically provides that online services are generally not responsible for “publishing” harmful user-generated content. Section 230 protects users’ online speech by protecting the intermediaries we all rely on to communicate via dating apps, social media, blogs, email, and other internet platforms.

The Ninth Circuit rightly affirmed the district court’s dismissal of all of the plaintiff’s claims. The court held that Section 230 bars nearly all of plaintiff’s claims (except the sex trafficking claim, which is exempted from Section 230). The court stated:

Each of Doe’s state law claims necessarily implicates Grindr’s role as a publisher of third-party content. The theory underpinning Doe’s claims for defective design, defective manufacturing, and negligence faults Grindr for facilitating communication among users for illegal activity….

The Ninth Circuit’s holding is important because many plaintiffs have tried in recent years to plead around Section 230 by framing their cases as seeking to hold internet platforms responsible for their own “defective designs,” rather than third-party content. Yet, a closer look at a plaintiff’s allegations often reveals that the plaintiff’s harm is indeed premised on third-party content—that’s true in this case, where the plaintiff exchanged messages with the adult men. As we argued in our brief:

Plaintiff’s claim here is based not on mere access to the app, but on the actions of a third party once John Doe logged in—messages exchanged between a third party and Doe, and ultimately, on unlawful acts occurring between them because of those communications.

Additionally, courts generally have concluded that an internet platform’s features that relate to how users can engage with the app and how third-party content is displayed and organized, are also “publishing” activities protected by Section 230.

As for the federal civil sex trafficking claim, the Ninth Circuit held that the plaintiff’s allegations failed to meet the statutory requirements. The court stated:

Doe must plausibly allege that Grindr ‘knowingly’ sex trafficked a person by a list of specified means. But the [complaint] merely shows that Grindr provided a platform that facilitated sharing of messages between users.

While the facts of this case are no doubt difficult, the Ninth Circuit reached the correct conclusion. Our modern communications are mediated by private companies, and any weakening of Section 230 immunity for internet platforms would stifle everyone’s ability to communicate, as companies would be incentivized to engage in greater censorship of users to mitigate their legal exposure.

This does not leave victims without redress—they may seek to hold perpetrators responsible directly. Importantly in this case, three of the perpetrators were held criminally liable. And should facts show that an online service participated in criminal conduct, Section 230 would not block a federal prosecution. The court’s ruling demonstrates that Section 230 is working as Congress intended.

広島AIプロセス・フレンズグループ会合の開催結果

信書便年報（令和6年度版）の公表

我が国のインターネットにおけるトラヒックの集計・試算

AIを用いた通信負荷の低減・通信量の確保等の検証に関する実証団体の公募

広域連携による市町村事務の共同実施モデル構築事業の委託団体の決定

戸籍の附票の写し又は戸籍の附票の除票の写しの交付に関する省令の一部を改正する省令（案）に対する意見募集

「令和6年度2月期における地方譲与税譲与金の譲与」

電波法施行規則等の一部を改正する省令案等に係る意見募集

令和6年度一般会計予備費の使用に伴う地方負担への対応等

村上総務大臣閣議後記者会見の概要

第214回統計委員会

デジタル空間における情報流通の諸課題への対処に関する検討会 デジタル空間における情報流通に係る制度ワーキンググループ（第2回）配付資料

「サービス産業動向調査」2024年（令和6年）12月分及び10〜12月期（速報）

2020年基準 消費者物価指数 東京都区部 2025年(令和7年)2月分(中旬速報値)

Join EFF's Cindy Cohn and Eva Galperin in conversation with Ron Deibert of the University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab, to discuss Ron’s latest book: Chasing Shadows: Cyber Espionage, Subversion and the Global Fight for Democracy. Chasing Shadows provides a front-row seat to a dark underworld of digital espionage, dark PR, and subversion. The book provides a gripping account of how the Citizen Lab, the world’s foremost digital watchdog, has uncovered dozens of cyber espionage cases and protects people in countries around the world. Called “essential reading” by Margaret Atwood, it’s a chilling reminder of the invisible invasions happening on smartphones and computers around the world.

LEARN MORE

When:

Monday, March 10, 2025 
7:oo pm - 9:o0 pm (PT)

Where:

In-person:
City Lights Bookstore
261 Columbus Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94133

Virtual:
Zoom

About the Author:

Ronald J. Deibert is the founder and director of the Citizen Lab, a world-renowned digital security research center at the University of Toronto. The bestselling author of Reset: Reclaiming the Internet for Civil Society and Black Code: Surveillance, Privacy, and the Dark Side of the Internet, he has also written many landmark articles and reports on espionage operations that infiltrated government and NGO computer networks. His team’s exposés of the spyware that attacks journalists and anti-corruption advocates around the world have been featured in The New York Times, The Washington Post, Financial Times, and other media. Deibert has received multiple honors for his cutting-edge work, and in 2022 he was appointed an Officer of the Order of Canada—the country’s second-highest honor of merit.

　新聞の「常識」から外れた、「異端」の記者と編集者の苦悩を鮮やかに描いた。取り上げたのは福岡、沖縄、秋田、岩手、兵庫、広島に本社を置く6地方紙と朝日新聞。新聞協会賞に輝いた記事もあるが、成功譚ではない。　西日本新聞の章を紹介しよう。1992年2月、福岡県内の山中で小学生の女児2人が絞殺体で発見された。同紙は8月、「重要参考人浮かぶ　ＤＮＡ鑑定で判明」とスクープ、さらに福岡県警が2年後の94年9月にその男性参考人を逮捕する前日にも特報した。その後、男は死刑が確定し、2008年1..